161
Essays on Infinite Lifespans
Brad F. Mellon
One can see why in light of historical developments, pre-
venting suicide is included in various ethical formulations
and why Pennsylvania, for example, has established it as one
of four state interests. The movement in favor of a right to
die in our view needs to be assessed against the movement to
radically extend life. At the very least it is our hope that the
Institutes pronounced emphasis on life would serve to counter
any moves to allow autonomous premature death, or espe-
cially the unlawful taking of life (nonmaleficence). Although
the Institutes mission statement is directed toward ending
involuntary death, adding a position on voluntary death in
our view might serve to provide a more realistic perspective
on crucial life and death issues facing society.
CONCERNS
Although we have found support for the Institutes mission
among the ethical and theological principles derived from our
Judeo-Christian tradition, some concerns arise.
First, there is the obvious reality of death. An American
proverb contends that death and taxes are the only two cer-
tainties we can expect. The Hebrew and Christian Scriptures
likewise testify to deaths reality. If we revisit the Scriptures
that promote life (above), we find many of them mention
death as well. The testimony about immortality within the
human soul in Ecclesiastes 3:11 is tempered by a later passage
where the writer describes the aging process that brings us to
lifes end (Ecclesiastes 12:17). Shortly after Jesus affirma-
tion of life in John 10:10 (see above), he clearly indicates that
eternal life exists beyond this one (John 14:14). Pope John
Paul II affirms the profound meaning of life on earth, yet says
that human life far exceeds the temporal plane because it is
bound up in the very life of God. [3] Drane reminds us that